HP resolves case with Ninestar

Mar 19, 2007

HP resolves ink cartridge patent infringement with Ninestar

HP has resolved ink cartridge patent violation issues with China-based Ninestar.  

As part of the settlement, Ninestar acknowledges the validity of HP’s patents and has agreed to stop selling the cartridges in question in the United States and certain other countries where such patents are held.

In July 2006, HP notified Ninestar of patent infringements of its replacement “clone” cartridges that are compatible with several HP printers. HP filed complaints with both the U.S. District Court and the International Trade Commission.

 
Ninestar has declined to comment at this stage, but Recycler has arranged an interview with Ninestar later this month.

Recycler has contacted HP to ask for further details, and we will publish these if they are forthcoming.

There will be an article in the May issue of The Recycler magazine which will look into this story.

Search The News Archive